Parsha Bemidbar: Numbers 1:1-4:20

The Sinai wilderness serves as more than a mere geographic backdrop for the reception of the Torah; it provides a necessary theological environment. In the Midrashic tradition, specifically in Bamidbar Rabbah (1:7), the Sages ask why the Torah was not given in the fertile land of Israel or within the walls of a grand city.

From this midrash, we see that the sages conclude that the Torah was given in a place that is hefker—ownerless and open to all. This status of the wilderness ensures that no single tribe or individual can claim exclusive ownership over the Divine word. The sages seem to indicate that by receiving the law in a no-man's-land, the Israelites established that the Torah is a universal inheritance for any person willing to enter the "desert" to find it.

I would like to posit that we must clarify that not all desert lands should be entered into. Hosea, for instance, mentions that when the people of Israel sin, we become like dry, Negev land--we do not have the water of Hashem, which is His Torah (The fountain of Living water (see Jeremiah 17:12-14)).

If we connect this ideology with concepts we have learned from our studies of Genesis, we can perhaps consider a deeper meaning of the wilderness. We learned in our Genesis studies that one of the first acts of creation was for Hashem to separate the waters so that dry land could form. We mentioned in a previous study that it was from this dry land that Adam was formed. While most pass over this statement as non-significant, we postulated that the formation of Adam from dry ground actually pointed to the eternal marriage covenant that Hashem would later make with the Jewish Israelites.

We mentioned that later in passages like Hosea 2:20-25, that due to the marriage covenant that He provided with the Israelites at Sinai, He promises to take back His Jewish people even when we stray into sin. This "taking back" (or redemption, to use a term from our previous studies in Leviticus 27) is promised by Hashem to come at no cost to us Jews. Rather, He promises to take us back "like Negev Land"--that is like dry land, like a bride without a bride price.

Furthermore, the wilderness represents a state of intellectual and spiritual "emptiness" that must precede true acquisition. To receive the Torah, you must view yourself, even momentarily, as hefker—open and unattached to previous biases or ego-driven identities. This allows the Divine wisdom to occupy the space that you have cleared.

By giving us the Torah in the wilderness, Hashem also seems to remind us that we came from dust. He promised Adam in Genesis 3 that we would return to dust, lest we grab hold of the tree of life and live forever. It just so happens that the Torah is the Tree of Life! When Hashem gave us the Torah on Mount Sinai, the Hebrews were in deed like the dry ground in which Hashem gave the Torah: steeped in 430 years of Egyptian mindset of survival mode, there was often doubt and fear that Hashem would again leave us. Because our souls were dry like the desert by which we were surrounded by, our souls could handle--indeed needed--the outpouring of the water of living water (The Torah). Dry ground, like a dry sponge, can absorb water quickly--in this way, the Torah (or the ketubah between Hashem and His chosen Jewish people) drenched our dry souls and provided the water necessary for Israel to bloom into the Nation of Hashem.

The Wilderness & The Concept of Hefker (ownerless property)

 The wilderness was ownerless--it was not the land that Hashem had promised the Jewish people. It was not the promised land of inheritance. The wilderness, therefore was not to be under the ownership of the Israelites.

The Ramban in his commentary on Numbers 1:1 states:

From this comment by the Ramban we can understand that the first accounting of the Jewish people occurred in the wilderness, with the goal of then moving away and out of the wilderness. If we connect this comment of the Ramban with the promise of Hashem in Genesis 3:15, the picture becomes even clearer.

In Genesis 3:15 Hashem promised that the seeds of Havah (the mother of all living) would one day crush the head of the Adversary. Just as Adam was formed from the dust, so the seeds that would redeem the entire world (the Jewish people) are here born in the land of the dust--the wilderness. In order for the seeds of the Jewish people to grow into the nation that could redeem the world, Hashem first had to provide the water necessary for the seeds to grow into a people of His righteousness.

It is from the seeds of Hashem's people that light is promised to come to the entire world. Indeed, in Isaiah 42:5-7, Hashem declares:

From this we learn that the Torah was given to the Jewish People by Hashem so that the glory, righteousness, and knowledge of Hashem could be dispersed throughout the world. In the end, Hashem promises that ALL nations will see, know, and honor Hashem as the One True God because they will know and understand His Torah.

 In this way, we can understand what the Midrash means when it explains that just as the wilderness does not belong to any one person, the words of the Torah are not the private domain of the elite, the wealthy, or the powerful. If the Torah had been given in the territory of Judah, the members of that tribe might have claimed a superior right to its secrets. By choosing the Sinai peninsula, the Divine Designer signaled that the Torah is a public gift. To acquire it, you do not need social status or land; you only need the willingness to walk into the open space of study.

Fire, Water, and Desert

The Sages further elaborate that the Torah was given through three specific media:

1. fire,

2. water, and

3. the desert.

The sages not that each of these elements shares the quality of being free and accessible to all inhabitants of the earth. Yet, we can also consider that each of the elements point specifically to Hashem.

1. Fire provides warmth and light.

   1. More significantly the fire that was present when the Torah was given in the wilderness was the very holy presence of Hashem Himself. This presence of Holy fire is in fulfillment of the promise that Hashem made to Abraham in Genesis 15. There when Hashem was making the eternal covenant with Abraham and his offspring, Hashem appeared in the form of a pillar of fire. This pillar of fire is what appeared on the tope of Sinai--the glory Presence of Hashem.

2. Water sustains life and purifies.

   1. More significantly, in the exodus and wilderness narratives, there was very little water except when Hashem made it appear through miracles. The splitting of the rocks, the appearance of 12 springs in the desert--these abundant bodies of water symbolize the Torah, which Hashem promises is the Fountain of Living water (Jeremiah 17:14). Each outpouring of water in the desert was followed with the promise that if the Jewish people would keep the promises of Hashem, then He would provide blessings, provisions, and life to all.

3. The desert provides the space for movement and revelation.

   1. The desert also figures the soul that does not have the spiritual water of Torah. Again, like Negev Land, Hashem does promise to redeem such a dry Jewish soul with an eternal covenantal, loving marriage relationship.

By linking the Torah to these three elements, the tradition emphasizes that the law is as essential to human survival as heat, hydration, and physical space.

The choice of the desert as the place where Hashem chose to give His Torah also highlights a paradox of Jewish existence. The desert is a place of scarcity and danger, yet it was the only place where the nation could be completely dependent on the Divine. In a settled land, you might attribute your success to the quality of your soil or the strength of your walls. In the wilderness, there is no such illusion. The "bread" comes from the heavens (Manna) and the "water" comes from a rock. This total dependency created the ideal psychological conditions for the Israelites to accept a legal system that demanded total loyalty to a Transcendent Authority.

Humility as a Prerequisite for Wisdom

The physical characteristics of the Sinai desert—its low mountains and barren plains—mirror the internal trait of humility (anavah). The fact that the land was barren gave the stark contrast of emptiness, which was then filled with Hashem's holy presence.

Or HaChaim commenting on Numbers 1:1 states:

Or HaChayim, trans. Eliyahu Munk

Source: urimpublications.com

Digitization: Sefaria

License: CC-BY

In Judaism, we believe that inside of every Jew resides a spark of Hashem. Connecting this concept with the comments of our great sage, Or HaChaim above, we can understand that we are like the desert. Since Hashem is present inside of all of us, we (like the desert) are secondary considerations--Hashem does not need us, but He chose us. He needs nothing from us, yet desires a deep and loving relationship with us. He could reveal His own glory without us, yet He desired to present to the world through us. When we realize that we are secondary, we can humbly accept the ways in which Hashem chooses to use us for His purposes and His glory. We can become like the empty vessel of the wilderness, into which Hashem can pour in His wisdom that allows us to shine His and radiate His light.

Essential Lessons of the Wilderness Setting

The desert setting provides several foundational principles for the student of Parsha Bamidbar:

• Accessibility: No person is barred from the heights of scholarship due to their background or location. The entire world is welcome to learn, understand, and keep Torah, by which the entire world can receive abundant life, love, and shalom.

• Dependency: True wisdom begins with the fear of Hashem (Proverbs 1:7). This fear is holy reverence. It is the understand that Hashem is everything. Without Him, nothing exists, including ourselves. The reverence should lead to the realization that we are dependent on a source higher than ourselves for our "sustenance."

• Renunciation: To gain the Torah, one must be willing to "leave" the comforts of worldly assumptions and animalistic desires and venture to answer the call to go chase after holiness.

• Equanimity: Like our ancestors in the desert, who needed to learn how to trust Hashem not their fears, the student of Torah must seek Hashem and ask Him for inner stability that is not shaken by external circumstances.

By starting the book of Numbers in the wilderness, the narrative reminds us that the journey toward the Promised Land is not just a physical trek, but a mental transition from the slave labor mentality of Egypt, that was over laden with the Iron Yoke of torturous tasks  to the "open desert" of Divine service. The scarcity of the desert would teach the Israelites to trust Hashem for everything. It was also the way to prove to them that He was nothing like the gods of Egypt who demanded they make the same amount of bricks without enough resources. Instead, Hashem led His people to a land without enough physical resources to prove to them that He was all sufficient to meet every single one of our needs. The only requirement: we keep His mitzvot--or the vows of our marriage covenant with Him.

Finally, the organization of the camp, the census of the tribes, and the duties of the Levites all take place within this framework of dry, humble space. This wilderness was the perfect picture of the wider world that steeped in the sins of idolatry. From this dry and godless place, Hashem promised to plant His seed (the Jewish people), who He would use to birth abundant light and life upon the earth. The census, the organization, and the formations of the people provided in this Parsha are Hashem's way of proving His promise: His nation was forming against all odds, as He promised to Abraham in Genesis 15. Though in the wilderness, and out of the line of direct sight, There Hashem Met with His beloved.

This affirms that we not look to men for approval. If we have Hashem, we have all the love, care, and acceptance we need.

Am Yisrael Chai!

Kimberly Davis

(All Text in italics)

Contributors: Our Great Sages

The Unkown sage of Bamidbar Rabbah

The Ramban

Or HaChayim